Those of you familiar with my site know that I love Frightened Rabbit. I discovered them two years ago (after they released The Midnight Organ Fight) and have been obsessed ever since. I even got a chance to chat with the band before one of their shows in San Francisco. Super nice guys!
So when I found out Frightened Rabbit was releasing a new album this year, it quickly became my most anticipated album of 2010. Considering the ridiculous number of bands releasing new material this year (including The National, Menomena, and Sun Kil Moon), this is quite a feat.
Luckily I didn’t have to wait too long for it. On March 9 Frightened Rabbit released The Winter of Mixed Drinks. After nearly three months of digesting it, I’m finally ready to share my thoughts.
Let me start by saying that following an album like The Midnight Organ Fight is pretty much impossible: release more of the same and critics attack you for stagnating; change your sound too much and your fan base revolts. On The Winter of Mixed Drinks, the band walks this fine line about as well as five inebriated Scotsmen possibly can. The album sounds bigger and more produced, which initially led me to believe it was more upbeat than The Midnight Organ Fight. But after repeated listens I realized I was horribly wrong. The album is brimming with tales of heartbreak, regret, and despair. You know, the stuff that makes us love Frightened Rabbit so much.
So while The Winter of Mixed Drinks ultimately succeeds as a follow-up, I’m not obsessed with it like I was with The Midnight Organ Fight. And I’ve finally figured out why. On The Midnight Organ Fight, the instrumentation and lyrics perfectly complement each other. But on The Winter of Mixed Drinks there is a disconnect between the two. As I mentioned above, the instrumentation is upbeat while the lyrics are quite the opposite. Because of this the album sounds slightly muddled, like the band is emerging from the shit-storm of emotion that was The Midnight Organ Fight.
Picking a favorite song from The Winter of Mixed Drinks is like picking a favorite beer: you really can’t go too wrong with whatever you choose (though some are definitely better than others). Right now my favorite is the aptly-titled “FootShooter.” It’s the most mellow track on the album and, coincidentally, features some of the best lyrics. I especially love the line “I will blink my eyes and hope the blink can erase / All the shit that I said and did.” Vintage Frightened Rabbit. Listen to it now.
[mp3] Frightened Rabbit :: FootShooter